Fake Meat O-Rama: Plant-Based vs Meatless Burgers

Kate Chynoweth
by Kate Chynoweth
Share it:
Fake Meat O-Rama: Plant-Based vs Meatless Burgers

Gone are the days when eating a meatless “burger” at a summer BBQ meant choking down a sad hockey puck of blackened plant protein. These fake meat burgers have really come a long way. In fact, we have meatless beef that bleeds. Even some certified carnivores are considering the switch to fake meat with an interest in the health benefits, sustainability and pro-animal welfare angle of eating plant protein.

Here’s a look at some of the best choices just in time for grilling season, plus few essential dos and don’ts so you can make every meat-free moment is as delicious as possible.


We’re living in the Renaissance Age of imposter beef. That’s what marketers want us to think, anyway, starting with the plant-based Beyond Burger, which is sold “raw” in the refrigerated section and purportedly delivers the “full 360° mouth-watering, juicy and delicious experience of beef.”

Made of peas, coconut oil and cleverly employed beet juice (for that all-important blood mimicry) these hefty patties resemble beef and layer handsomely in a sesame bun. However, as with most substitution foods, from rice “pasta” to vegan “cheese,” appreciating the flavor is a subjective situation.

The Beyond Meat folks also have a new product, Beyond Sausage, that recently arrived in Whole Foods markets. Varieties include: Original Bratwurst, Hot Italian and Sweet Italian. Start by trying the Bratwurst with sauerkraut and mustard in a soft bun.

Perhaps you’ve also heard of the super trendy Impossible Burger, a non-meat patty that nonetheless “smells, sizzles and bleeds” like the real thing, according to its website. Want it for your next barbecue? Sorry, it’s not in retail stores yet, and can be found only at select restaurants. That said, if you’re curious to try it, you can easily check online to see if it’s on a menu near you. (Most large cities do have spots that serve it.)

This vegetarian tester wasn’t a fan of the taste of either the Beyond or the Impossible burgers, preferring the flavor of veggie- and grain-based burgers over the products designed to mimic raw meat. (Full disclosure: I never liked the taste of real beef to begin with.)


“Raw” non-meat burgers might be trendy, but don’t overlook the tried-and-true products in the freezer aisle. Just be sure not to confuse burger-like patties with veggie patties: The former will be brown and look (a little bit) like frozen beef. For burger-like patties, try Whole Foods brand 365 Meatless Burgers or Morning Star Farms Grillers Original Burgers. Both have a flavor and texture reminiscent of frozen sausage.

Veggie burgers, on the other hand, visibly show grains and colorful veggies and rarely brown up the same way — a good example is Dr. Praeger’s California Veggie Burgers.



Nutrition-wise, the “burger-alternative” style patty tends to be lower in carbs and higher in protein than its veggie burger counterpart, which fits into current lifestyle and diet trends. For example, the Beyond Burger has 5 grams of carbs and 20 grams of protein; the Whole Foods 365 Alternative Burger has 7 grams of carbs and 11 grams of protein. This is fewer carbs than you’ll find in grain-or bean-based veggie burgers: Dr. Praeger’s California Veggie Burger has 13 grams of carbs and 4 grams of protein; Hilary’s World’s Best Garden Burger has 27 grams of carbs and 4 grams of protein. The upshot? Check every label if carbs are a concern for you.


Cook meatless patties gently. Because these “burgers” lack the natural fattiness of beef they can taste worse than cardboard if exposed to careless high-heat cooking. In fact, many alternative meat products taste better when fried in a pan instead of blasted on the grill; they also cook quickly, so avoid overdoing it. Don’t forget the fixins: melted cheese, fresh tomato, crunchy lettuce, creamy avocado and sliced pickles can help overcome any texture or flavor issues, so that meatless burger satisfies you from the first bite.


About the Author

Kate Chynoweth
Kate Chynoweth

Kate’s writing about food and lifestyle has appeared in The Huffington Post, Live Happy, Real Simple and Sunset. She’s also the author of “Lemons,” “The Bridesmaid Guide” and other books. She lives in Berkeley, California, where she enjoys lowbrow pop culture and top-shelf booze.


10 responses to “Fake Meat O-Rama: Plant-Based vs Meatless Burgers”

  1. Avatar Marcel86 says:

    I find it odd meatless burgers meant to taste like real beef are being reviewed by someone who “…never liked the taste of real beef to begin with.”

  2. Avatar Thales Nemo says:

    Why eat fake foods , go for the real food instead. If you want a burger have a real grass fed one , accept no substitutes. If you don’t then don’t have it but there are way too many fake foods available!

    • Avatar Kelly says:

      I think its more of a morality thing for some and others the health benefits of a plant based diet, along with individuals trying to avoid red meat due to the recent world health organisation classification. I personally prefer my burgers with natural plant based ingredients but on occasion crave a junk food burger and it’s nice to have that option as we all like a treat. I have never had a beyond meat burger so cannot comment on the taste but the ingredients are natural without gmo’s, trans fats, cholesterol, gluten or dairy. It’s also nice to be able to purchase a plant based burger without having to cook and put it in the food processor, make it into patties and that’s if you get the texture right. If they were in the uk I would be happy to buy these.

    • Avatar Linda J Nichols says:

      Fake food?
      I wouldn’t call these “burgers” fake as all the ingredients are real food and not manufactured chemical food. It’s just that it isn’t an animal product.

  3. Avatar irmasue says:

    The Beyond Meat burgers are delicious! I was very pleasantly surprised. I’m a whole lot happier living with a clear conscience, but did miss the taste of a good burger!

  4. Avatar Kate Paullin says:

    This vegetarian also prefers veggie and black bean burgers. I don’t want my food to bleed—that’s kind of the point of my being veg in the first place!

  5. Avatar Dave says:

    Good write up, however, I’d recommend that fat content be a talking point in articles like these. Beyond Meat is a good meat substitute but it’s saturated fat content is insanely high.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Never Miss a Post!

Turn on MyFitnessPal desktop notifications and stay up to date on the latest health and fitness advice.


Click the 'Allow' Button Above


You're all set.

You’re taking control of your fitness and wellness journey, so take control of your data, too. Learn more about your rights and options. Or click here to opt-out of certain cookies.