Are You Going Overboard on Fat?

by Jessica Migala
Share it:
Are You Going Overboard on Fat?

Whereas you may have limited your fat five years ago, today it’s common to hear health experts recommend adding avocado to your salads and toast or snacking on full-fat yogurt, almonds and cheese. Research has shown fad diets — such as low-fat or low-carb — which cut large food groups from your diet may be short-term fixes but won’t help you sustain weight loss in the long run.

“Fat is a very controversial macronutrient,” says Atlanta-based sports nutritionist Ilana Katz, MS, RD. What’s clear is it’s necessary for everyone regardless of activity level. “Fat has many very important functions in physiology, from being a part of every cell membrane to immune function enhancement to protection of vital organs,” she says. Not to mention, the addition of fat to your meals helps your body properly absorb fat-soluble nutrients like vitamins A, D and K.


Ramping up fat intake at the expense of other macronutrients (like carbs and protein) can negatively affect brain function and hamper performance in the gym. While the keto diet (which promotes eating 90% of your calories from fat) is generating a lot of buzz for weight loss, it isn’t known how the diet affects the body long-term, which makes experts wary. Its restrictive nature makes it hard to sustain and could lead to nutrient deficiencies by cutting out multiple food groups.

Instead, many health experts recommend getting roughly 20–35% of your calories from fat, says Amy Goodson, MS, RD, a sports nutritionist based in Dallas. “However, it depends on the type of person and his or her goals,” she says. For example, if you’re training for a half-marathon or long cycling event, you may opt to consume even less to make room for more carb calories, which is a main source of energy during endurance training.


Stick to monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats, says Goodson. Avocado, nuts, seeds, nut butters, fatty fish (salmon, sardines) and oils (olive oil, avocado oil) all fall under the umbrella of healthy fats. These, according to the American Heart Association, are best for heart health.

As for saturated fat, these have recently earned a health halo thanks to trendy foods like coconut oil and ghee. Organizations like the AHA point out that dietary saturated fat raises cholesterol, increasing heart disease risk. But some research shows saturated fat in certain foods, like dairy, doesn’t have a negative impact on cholesterol, says Goodson. Still, she recommends limiting saturated fat to the AHA’s recommended 10% or less of total calories. “It’s important to remember that not all saturated fats come in a nutrient-rich package,” she says. Goodson uses the example that full-fat dairy has saturated fat plus nine essential nutrients, whereas french fries certainly do not.

It is a good idea to avoid trans fat (found in processed and fried foods) altogether since we now know it’s associated with high cholesterol and an increased risk of developing cardiovascular disease.


Fat contains 9 calories per gram, while carbs and protein each have 4 per gram. You get nearly twice the calories per bite, Goodson points out. “People think almonds are good for me and eat 60 or avocado is a healthy fat and they eat a whole one. While supplying healthy fat, the added calories can contribute to weight gain if you’re exceeding your daily calorie budget,” she says.

What’s more, “since fat is the most caloric dense macronutrient, too much can negatively impact your energy balance,” says Katz, who notes that many endurance athletes struggle without a good source of carbs. “Beware of the belief that all fat fits because trendy diets say so.”

Fat is a healthy and necessary part of a balanced diet. No matter what source of fat you’re eating, when building your plate, consider healthy fats (nuts, avocado, cheese) as a complement to the complex carbohydrates and protein that make up your meal, says Goodson. That may be an apple and peanut butter, yogurt with berries and nuts or salmon with veggies and quinoa, she says.

About the Author

Jessica Migala

Jessica Migala is a health and fitness freelancer based in the Chicago suburbs. She spends her days writing with her beagle mix by her side and her free time with her two young sons. Jessica also writes for O, The Oprah magazine, Woman’s Day, Real Simple and others. Find her at


Never Miss a Post!

Turn on MyFitnessPal desktop notifications and stay up to date on the latest health and fitness advice.


Click the 'Allow' Button Above


You're all set.